The other day at dinner, my friend Scott decided to lighten the mood by playing a little guessing game. He said, “Guess what?” and before I could respond, he revealed he had a surprise for dessert. Naturally, I started rattling off the usual suspects: chocolate cake, ice cream, maybe even a fruit tart! So, when he finally announced, “I got a giant jar of pickles!” I couldn’t help but burst into laughter. He clearly saw a dessert option through a very unique lens.
It’s the classic expectations vs. reality moment; who goes from anticipating a sweet treat to celebrating a jar of pickles? Instead of a sugary delight, his idea of a culinary surprise turned out to be the weirdest party trick ever! Not only did it sound like a prank, but suddenly we were debating which condiment pairs best with what can only be described as a sour twist on dessert. All I could think was, if only I had known, I would’ve come armed with peanut butter instead of a fork!
in Funny
Can You Guess?

K
I know its a real pic because the tags are expired
M
Fellow Coloradan I see.
C
Came to the comments for this.
F
Guess who?
H
Subaru.
S
No, honda pilot.
S
No one ever expects the ~~spanish inquisition~~ Honda pilot
M
😂
T
That ‘Guess What?’ + CHKNBUT combo is elite dad humor branding and I respect the commitment.
L
I paid $250 (technically donated!) to a non-profit for a brick in a park that says ‘knock knock, who’s there, Lordyeti’. One of my favorite purchases ever!
T
J
Okay now i get it
F
Chicken Boo. “He wears a disguise to look like human guys but he’s not a man he’s a chicken boo.”
N
He’s a giant chicken, I tell ya!
I
that license plate + sticker combo is the most committed chicken joke I’ve ever seen.
Z
Chickens, two.
R
Chicken Poo Guess why.
U
Chicken Thigh Guess when?
R
Chicken hen? (Redundancy) Wanna know the rest?
G
Me.
P
C0cknbut
I
Guess why?
N
Chicken thigh!
P
Chicken thigh..
P
Your butts dry
L
Cow pie. How come? God you’re dumb.
L
Chicken pie?
J
My 6-year-old constantly asks me to guess what. I can’t convey the level of self control it takes me to not answer with “Chicken Butt!” every damn time.
A
I work in a daycare and one child kept asking “guess what” and one time I answered “chicken butt.” Soon like 6 kids were constantly saying “guess what chicken butt” and I had to apologize for teaching it to them.
J
This is why I don’t want to say it to my kid, because then I know I’ll hear it 29 times a day, everyday, until he’s 12.
N
It’s that or “6-7” man, pick your poison. I for one choose chicken butts!
A
It doesn’t stop at 12. My kids (17 and 12) get me with this shit all the time. I legit haven’t said it to them in 10 years, and they get me at least once a month.
N
Give in. It is your destiny. Eventually, they’ll say it back to you. And thats when you know you’ve raised them right.
D
Mine is almost 8 and still says guess what I I’ve been saying chicken butt for his whole life and it doesn’t phase him. We are at a stalemate
A
I might be a terrible parent. My 7 year old has started saying, “Guess what?” And I always answer “Chicken butt…”
T
Someone cross-posting this to /r/PeterExplainsTheJoke and /r/ExplainTheJoke in 5…4…3…
B
The alt askreddit
W
Rarely is a vanity plate worth the money… this is that time.
L
poor buckley
S
Guess how? Chicken cow.
T
I thought I was the only one.
T
Dang… ol’… Mega-Lo-Mart… done git went got it, and dang ol’ boom!
A
Guess where?
U
Underwear
Z
Chicken there.
C
Do your thing CHKNBUT Pilot
R
the level of commitment it takes to get a custom plate just to finish a joke is honestly impressive
A
Ahhh okay, the plate is the finish. I was so annoyed at this picture because the chicken came before Guess What? I am less annoyed now
C
Guess why.
T
Chicken pie
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings